At Flavorpill, vintage covers of The Phantom Tollbooth from all over the world. The 2006 German edition is particularly gorgeous, as is the ethereal 2007 Chinese cover. But who in their right mind would junk Jules Feiffer’s illustrations?
–Emily Gordon
Monthly Archives: October 2011
The Great Kate Beaton on Drawing for The New Yorker
From a recent A.V. Club interview about Kate Beaton‘s essential new book, Hark! A Vagrant. The as-close-to-universally-beloved-as-it’s-possible-to-get-without-being-a-baby-panda Beaton and cartoonist Sam Means had a cartoon in the June 28 issue of the magazine (as “Beans,” which is a great combi-name). Are more forthcoming? Only Bob Mankoff knows for sure.
AVC: How did you get involved with _The New Yorker_? Did they come to you, or did you go to them?
**KB**: No, you have to submit to them. You give them packages. _The New Yorker_ doesn’t come to anybody, not even the people who’ve been published there for 20 years. You have to submit, and you just keep doing it until they buy one.
**AVC: What’s it like doing comics for them?**
**KB**: It’s just a different audience–and by “audience,” I mean the _New Yorker_ editor who buys your comic or doesn’t, and he’s the guy you want to really impress. I could do anything I wanted on my site, but I just wanted to get in somewhere where an editor said, “This is good enough,” or, “This is not good enough.” There’s a certain _New Yorker_ sensibility, style, sense of humor, that I thought about when I was making them, like, “I want this to look like a _New Yorker_ cartoon.” And I thought that’s how I should go about it. I didn’t write them, Sam Means wrote them, and I drew them. We had a partnership. But recently, I was on a panel with Roz Chast. She’s amazing, and she was like, “You shouldn’t adhere to any style, you should just do what you wanna do. You shouldn’t make it look like a New Yorker cartoon, you should make it look like yours.” Which I never really considered. [Laughs.] I mean, _The New Yorker_’s kind of an institution. But she probably is right. I enjoyed doing it, but maybe I would enjoy it more if I had stuck to my own sensibilities more. I don’t know.
See, we do sometimes still write about The New Yorker!
–Emily Gordon
