Jonathan Taylor writes:
My pick of the March 1 issue is the March 1 issue, just for provoking a Pick of the Issue post. Larissa MacFarquhar’s Profile of Paul Krugman is eye-catching, prima facie, though I’d like to see a piece looking more broadly at the world of economics blogging that Krugman is now engaged with via his Times blog. That could bring us full circle, via Tyler Cowen of George Mason University, to the subject of the issue of Calvin Trillin’s (gated) piece, peripatetic Sichuanese chef Peter Chang: This culinary legend of the U.S. Southeast is a central figure in Cowen’s extenstive Ethnic Dining Guide. (Note to Tyler, put Famous Sichuan on Pell Street, and Grand Sichuan House of Bay Ridge on your New York City to-do list.)
My real pick is Ben McGrath’s “Strangers on the Mountain” (also not free online), the mountain being about 50 miles north of Krugman’s Princeton, in the Ramapo range (which Chang might still try if he really wants to disappear). Just when you think the piece is rather drearily going to be about a conflict between libertarian A.T.V. (and computer) users and the gummint (New Jersey park police), it takes the first in a series of sociological and historical turns that grabbed me over and over. McGrath points out that the so-called Jackson Whites—a.k.a. Ramapo Mountain People, or the Ramapough Lenape Nation—were the subject of some dubious reporting by The New Yorker in 1938, as well as by the Times and others since the 19th century.
Old treatments of the topic by the NAACP magazine The Crisis in 1939, and the Southern Workman, journal of an “industrial school for Negro youth,” in 1911, among others, can be found through Google Books.
Category Archives: Pick of the Issue
Best of the 10.26.09 Issue: Peter Hessler, Finding the Center
Jonathan Taylor writes:
The world does not revolve around you: It’s the most basic experience of the traveler. Elaborating on the concrete ways this truth manifests itself is the most basic structure of travel narrative—but one that too often, paradoxically, cements the observer at the center of things. Peter Hessler’s dispatches from China are a lesson in overcoming this solipsism, and his “Letter from Lishui,” in the October 26 issue, takes points of view on “the outside world” as its topic of characteristically agile inquiry. (Subscribers only; free audio slide show here.)
Lishui is about 200 miles southwest of Shanghai, a bit inland from China’s Pacific coast. Its physical location is less important than its place in the global economy. It is a creature of the global economy because its factories produce components—”zippers, copper wiring, electric-outlet covers”—to be assembled by manufacturers elsewhere into finished goods. Yet it is at a firmly defined remove from the wider world. Representatives of foreign companies need not travel this far up China’s supply chain, and shrapnel of Western popular culture lands there in isolated bits: a gym called The Scent of a Woman, or a tattoo randomly reading Kent (the cigarette brand).
Hessler introduces “Little Long,” a dye factory technician who collects mangled self-help books like A Collection of the Classics, larded with dubious improving anecdotes about Western figures like Charles Darwin and John D. Rockefeller; and Wu Zengrong, who interacts with individuals a hemisphere away through an electronic veil, as a professional player of World of Warcraft.
Alongside Lishui’s fly-by-night pleather and bead factories, the government established something of a special district for the mass production of paintings, mostly kitschy old-world cityscapes. Any journalist could get a quick thrill out of describing a Chinese painting factory churning out thousands of scenes of Venice (known to the artists only a Shui Cheng, “Water City”), copying the details without a clue about what they are depicting. But Hessler cleverly uses these literal views of unknown places to illustrate the uses of information about the outside world in Lishui.
The degree of detail often impressed me. The outside world might be distant, but it wasn’t necessarily blurred; people caught discrete glimpses of things from overseas. In many cases, these images seemed slightly askew—they were focussed and refracted, like light bent around a corner. Probably it had something to do with all the specialization. Lishui residents learned to see the world in parts, and these parts had a strange clarity, even when they weren’t fully understood.
Hessler notes the distinctive way that residents of Lishui jump nimbly from one wave to the next in the senseless tides of the global economy, making do for themselves with little care why the world suddenly no longer wants pleather, but needs beaded shoes or hair bands instead. But when you consider those words by themselves, you can’t help but think that they apply, in their own way, to “us,” or any people planted any place on Earth.
Hessler loops back around to the U.S. to complete his point, which is not about China, or about art factories, but rather might be that the wider our global horizons, the more salient their limitations. A painting factory had received a commission from an unknown customer, via a middleman, to create art based on a series of photographs of what turned out to be Park City, Utah. Hessler shows pictures of the paintings, and the painters, to Park City folks. Mayor Dana Williams is excited that their local sites have gained global fame of a sort; others are suspicious or depressed by the subjection of their hometown to the low-cost foreign paintbrush. But Hessler’s plain tone, unchanged from when he’s in Lishui, allows Park City to take shape as another little place peering out at “the outside world” in curious fragments.
Mayor Williams knows a few words of Chinese and talks offhand about “the Tao”; his office is littered with calligraphic scrolls and a copy of Mao’s “Little Red Book” that he mines for “the useful stuff” (“Serve the people”). He is a mirror of Little Long, who knows just the English words for his nylon dyes (“Sellanyl Yellow N-5GL”) and learns from his A Collection of the Classics that Rockefeller wisely berated a waiter for complaining small-mindedly about a measly tip.
Everyone is the center of their own world, after all.
Experience Gopnik and McLemee Virtually, This Saturday
Martin Schneider writes:
This, from the National Book Critics Circle, made its way to my in-box:
How reviewers are adapting to the new digital order has been one of the burning themes among NBCC members for the past year. NBCC board member Scott McLemee sends along notice of his own intervention of sorts: On Saturday, from 5 to 7 PM EST, he’ll be hosting an on-line book salon about Adam Gopnik’s Angels and Ages at Firedoglake.com. The transcripts of previous FDL salons, which have featured contributors ranging from Thomas Ricks to Rick Perlstein are here.
How intriguing! I’m sure that’ll be terrific.
Best of the 03.23.09 Issue: Tantrum
Martin Schneider writes:
Barry Blitt’s vision of eight wailing Limbaughs was on the cover. Features included Jeffrey Toobin’s look at Roland Burris, Keith Gessen’s report on the Politkovskaya murder trial, and John McPhee’s article on lacrosse.
More to come!
Best of the 03.16.09 Issue: You Go, Girl
Martin Schneider writes:
The Style Issue! Floc’h’s vision of multiple Michelle Obamas on the catwalk was on the cover. Features included Lauren Collins’s report on Bill Cunningham, Judith Thurman’s article on Yasmina Reza, and Ariel Levy’s look at Alber Elbaz.
Best of the 03.09.09 Issue: Masters of the Universe
Martin Schneider writes:
Bob Staake’s takedown of Wall Street CEOs was on the cover. Features included Ian Parker’s report on Iceland’s economic collapse, D.T. Max’s look at the life of David Foster Wallace, and Sasha Frere-Jones’s appreciation of Lily Allen.
Best of the 03.02.09 Issue: Hive Mind
Martin Schneider writes:
Ivan Brunetti’s adorable presentation of cubicle life was on the cover. Features included Ryan Lizza’s report on Rahm Emanuel, Rebecca Mead’s Profile on soprano Natalie Dessay, and Steve Koll’s investigation of tensions between Pakistan and India.
Best of the 02.23.09 Issue: An Issue on Steroids
Martin Schneider writes:
Barry Blitt’s satire of Alex Rodriguez was on the cover. Features included Daniel Zalewski’s article on Ian McEwan, Jane Mayer’s look at the Obama administration’s detainee policy, and Evan Ratliff’s report on military robots.
Best of the 02.09-16.09 Issue: Updike, and Then Some
Martin Schneider writes:
This issue had a familiar fop on the cover. Candidates include Evan Osnos on African merchants in China, John McPhee on fact-checking, and George Packer on land values in Florida. Of course, one might execute an end-run around the whole question by selecting the Updike retrospective. As always—more to come.
Best of the 02.02.09 Issue: Al Roosten and Army Cats
Martin Schneider writes:
This issue had Adrian Tomine’s cover wryly commenting on the region’s tough winter. (I’d like to say that this cover took me a while to get, because I wasted precious seconds looking for the Obama connection.) Candidates include Larissa MacFarquhar on Caroline Kennedy, Laura Secor on Mohammed Tabibian, and Kelefa Sanneh on Booker T. Washington. You guessed it—this post is not yet complete!
Martin Schneider adds: Having now looked at the issue more carefully, I’m going to single out Nancy Franklin’s evocative roundup of the cable news coverage of the inauguration. It was funny (any sentence referencing Chris Matthews) and the ending had a nice jolt of earned profundity. Brava!
