A couple days after it premiered, Jason Kottke unveiled his “review”:http://www.kottke.org/08/11/the-new-yorkers-online-digital-reader-an-evaluation of the New Yorker Digital Edition. (Here’s my “summary”:http://emdashes.com/2008/11/the-new-yorker-digital-edition.php.) I think he’s speaking a lot of truth there. But then few people bring it like Kottke.